Schopenhauer's Concept of The Will

75

By John Sarkis

Will and Idea

Some people are great on their own merit - some people are great because of the influence they exerted upon others. If one was to measure Arthur Schopenhauer's greatness, he'd probably fall on the latter of the two categories. Schopenhauer wasn't as startling a writer as Tolstoy or Borges were; he wasn't as great a philosopher as Nietzsche was; he wasn't as great a psychologist as Freud or Jung were; and he wasn't as great a scientist as Einstein was, but he influenced all of these great men with his unique and personal view of the human condition (human condition is a relative philosophical term used to describe what it means to be - live - and eventually die) which he referred to as "Will...."

The Renaissance was one of the most important periods in European history. Europeans began to question everything, and philosophy reverted back to how it was during the time of the Greeks. John Locke was very sober and methodical about his views on metaphysics and epistemology. So by the time Hegel came into the picture, nothing was left to chance. Furthermore, after The Enlightenment, many people started to doubt the existence of a supernatural being that oversees and controls human beings and the cosmos.

It's now the end of the 18th Century - Schopenhauer is born.

Schopenhauer was a hardcore atheist and thought little of organized religion. He was heavily influenced by Locke, Berkeley and Kant, however, he felt that they had all missed the mark somehow. He didn't fully understand European thought at the time. He understood philosophers and scientists questioning the existence of God, but the concept that people can vice themselves and be moral, was not something that he agreed with. Schopenhauer felt that so called 'normal and logical people' overspend money, they overeat, they oftentimes make poor choices in life when choosing a partner. So where is the logic in all of this? If God doesn't exist, and people think they can vice and control their behavior, why do so many people make so many mistakes throughout their lives. Most people aren't crazy or deranged. So where does all this futile and reckless human behavior come from?

It's now the beginning of the 19th Century - Schopenhauer is in his late twenties and finally comes up with an answer to his question which he termed "Will." According to Schopenhauer, it's because of the "Will" that we make so many egregious mistakes. "Will" - the irrational side of the brain which craves physical existence, but also the part of the brain which makes it impossible for human beings to be happy and reposed. The "Will to Live" concept as he called it. Schopenhauer felt that both Kant and Hegel were wrong to think that human beings could ever be ethical and moral....

Pros:

These days research has proven Schopenhauer wrong on some of his theories about human behavior. That being said, his theories about human sexual drive were taken up a notch by Darwin in his theory of "survival of the fittest"; however, when Darwin lived, Schopenhauer didn't yet have a following as he would have towards the end of the 19th Century.... Schopenhauer has been one of the most influential figures in history - from Wagner to Wittgenstein and beyond. Writers from all walks of life have been influenced by him in some way or another. "The World as Will and Representation" has been read by many, and quoted by even more (many individuals have only read portions of the book - parts of the book are brilliant, but others parts can be a bit on the tedious side...)

Cons:

Although Schopenhauer criticized Berkeley and Locke, many of his ideas came from them. "The World is my idea" has nothing new in it that Berkeley or even Locke couldn't have conjured up... Schopenhauer also criticized Kant to a great extent, but claimed exclusivity in being the only one that had truly understood him. Schopenhauer was also very hostile towards Hegel as well, yet many today consider Hegel to have been the more important of the two men. (that said, very few individuals have read Hegel because he's extremely difficult to comprehend...)



Comments

stessily profile image

stessily Level 8 Commenter 5 months ago

John, Your opening sentence perfectly describes two aspects of influence which are endlessly intriguing, especially on the philosophical path. Both aspects are necessary for puzzling our way through life's mysteries.

Schopenhauer's concept of will continues to encourage self-analysis and improvement. It sometimes seems to me that true free will concerns the alignment of all aspects of a human being, from spiritual to emotional to mental to physical. If Herr Schopenhauer had lived into his eighth decade, might he have seen things differently, and, if so, would he have admitted to them?

Thank you for the deep journey which so many of your hubs offer their readers, who, perhaps like me at distracted moments, are lulled into taking them at face value only afterwards to become conscious of ever-lengthening threads of thought and consciousness.

Kind regards, Stessily

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 5 months ago

Hi Stessily,

Hope you're doing well and enjoying the holidays with your family and loved ones....

Yes, the thing which has intrigued me about Schopenhauer is how many people he has influenced: Chekov, Proust, Shaw, etc................. However, I don't see that he said anything that Berkeley, Locke, Hume or Kant didn't before him. His niche is how he fused everything from the past and partially makes it work in his theories of human nature...

You take care of yourself and thanks for your comments, they're truly appreciated...

God Bless

John

AudreyHowitt profile image

AudreyHowitt Level 7 Commenter 2 months ago

John, I admit my ignorance of 20th century philosophers and must say that I enjoy reading about them through your eyes. Thank you.

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 2 months ago

Thanks Audrey for stopping by and commenting.

I'm glad you enjoyed the article.

Take good care of yourself and thanks again

John

AudreyHowitt profile image

AudreyHowitt Level 7 Commenter 2 months ago

My pleasure John

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 2 months ago

Thanks

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working