The Piano Concertos of Beethoven

74

By John Sarkis

Beethoven's 5 Piano Concertos

Note: you’ll find a ‘youtube’ link below every piano concerto discussed. However, there are myriads of performances/artists playing these 5 concertos in 'youtube' for you to explore and enjoy...

The Piano Concertos of Beethoven - Beethoven holds a unique position as one of music’s greatest geniuses - some have gone as far as to call him the greatest musical genius of all times. With that said, in viewing him closer on a mortal level, he was just another typical musician of his day trying to make ends meet, much like his contemporaries (e.g., Johann Nepomuk Hummel, Carl Maria von Weber and Muzio Clementi, etc..)

Beethoven, like the above aforementioned musicians in the first paragraph, was an exceptional performer - he was a great pianist and an above par conductor, so it should comes to no surprise that he’d write piano music for the purpose of showing off his virtuosic prowess...

Beethoven wrote five piano concertos. Beethoven's last two piano concertos are arguably the reason many have referred to him as the greatest musical genius of all times; the first three concertos could have arguably been written by an above average composer of his day, although the third concerto does contain excellent musical development (classical music is unique because it contains development, which is something that so called popular/strophic music typically does not …)

Piano Concerto No. 1 in C major op. 15 - composed 1796 and 1797

This is not the first piano concerto Beethoven wrote, but it's the first he published... Beethoven is not the first composer to have published compositions in the reverse chronological order in which he wrote them, Mendelssohn and Chopin published some of their works in reverse chronological order as well. (e.g., Mendelssohn's 5th Symphony 'Reformation', was written before his 3rd Symphony 'Scottish', but most people don't know this...)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFfUcQQbwsE

Piano Concerto No. 2 in B-flat major op. 19 - composed 1787 and 1789

This is actually Beethoven's first piano concerto, but it was published as his second concerti. I already explained this in my review of his first piano concerto. Beethoven was 17 years old when he began composing this piano concerto in 1787. The work is not Beethoven at his best, especially when you take into consideration the compositions which Mendelssohn and Mozart were writing at around the same age Beethoven was when he started to write this concerti...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pz1m5Y96IBU

Piano Concerto No. 3 in C minor op. 37 - composed in 1800

Beethoven has been credited with having been the first composer to have truly developed the minor key. The first movement of this work is very long in duration and shows exceptional development of the work's main themes...it's Beethoven's most famous piano concerto after the No. 5, and gets performed quite frequently these days, especially by young concert pianists who are starting to make their way into the world.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FetACZlj0_0

Piano Concerto No. 4 in G major op. 58 - composed 1805 and 1806

This work is a true marvel of composition, especially the slow movement (second movement). No one can do a slow movement like Beethoven, and this is proof of that. The slow section of this piano concerto is one of the most futuristic movements Beethoven composed, even if it's not as pleasant to listen to as the slow movement of the Emperor Concerto. (5th Piano Concerto)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cPTURzDAyY&feature=related

Piano Concerto No. 5 in E flat op. 73 "Emperor" composed 1809 and 1811

This slow section (2nd movement) of this work is one of the most beautiful compositions Beethoven or anyone has ever written - his most famous Piano Concerto by far.... A must hear for beginners to the world so called 'classical music'. (early Romantic actually)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5C7dtuikFE


Comments

KatrineDalMonte profile image

KatrineDalMonte Level 6 Commenter 4 months ago

Hi John, thanks for this informative article. Beethoven is one of my favorite classical composers. Voted up and away :-)

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 4 months ago

Thanks Katrine. Beethoven is also one of my favorites, glad you enjoyed my article...

...your articles are really insightful as well...good start for you unto HP...

Take care

John

Derdriu profile image

Derdriu Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

John, What a persuasive, practical, profound look at the Beethoven piano concertos 1 through 5! In particular, my favorites are the third and fifth, precisely for the reasons which you give. The clarinet was my musical instrument of choice, but Beethoven's concertos were among the compositions which made me appreciate the piano.

Thank you for sharing, voted up + all,

Derdriu

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thanks Derdriu!

Yes, the 5 is my favorite, followed by the 4.

I didn't know you played the clarinet. It's a wonderful instrument. I love the Mozart concerto.

God Bless

John

jamila sahar profile image

jamila sahar Level 3 Commenter 3 months ago

greetings john,

naturally, as a pianist i greatly admire beethoven, he is a powerful source of inspiration to me. additionally, i adore his slow movements as well, i am currently working on opus 31 no. 2 and the adagio is so beautiful and moving. i heard the ny philharmonic play beethoven's 'first' concerto at lincoln center in nyc, and it was such a memorable performance, it has stayed my favorite, but i have the score for 'the emporor's' as i plan to learn it one day, as requested by one of my professors. my first piano professor told me 'that is the ONE' ! thanks for sharing this great hub, i look forward to reading more !

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you jamila sahar

I'm impressed with your knowledge of music. Yes, I share much of the same sentiments when it comes to Beethoven.

Take care and God Bless

John

Lzaus 3 months ago

I too enjoy Beethoven piano concertos. I am particularly interested in the one comment you made, that he was the first to truly develop the minor key. I am very interested in minor key music and its impact on music for the last 100 years. I assume the first group to use minor key music was religious people many years before Beethoven.

What impact do you think Beethoven and/or minor key music had on the Tin Pan alley composers, many of whom were jewish? ie. Gershwin, Harold Arlen, Irving Berlin, etc.

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hello Lzaus, thanks for commenting and welcome to HP

What I find before Beethoven is that the minor key revolved mainly and stayed in the Tonic "I" and Dominant "V," but rarely left the main points of the scale. Beethoven gave the minor key (especially in the 5th Symphony) a certain "cocky attitude" if you will, never the likes of before him.

By the time Gershwin, Berlin, Porter and the likes came into the scene, Wagner and Debussy had revolutionized music for ever. It was these two gentlemen that really changed everything, Beethoven was just the tip of the iceberg, so to speak. In Wagner, chords have little to no relationship to each other and, by the time Debussy and Schoenberg came into the scene, chords and chromaticism were at will with little if any relationship to each other whatsoever....

Take care of yourself

John

kelleyward profile image

kelleyward Level 7 Commenter 12 days ago

Thanks John for sharing this. Beethoven is one of my absolute favorite composers. He had quite an interesting life it seems. Thanks for sharing this. Voted up! Take care, Kelley

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 11 days ago

Hi Kelleyward, and thanks for stopping by and commenting on my article.

Yes, I love Beethoven as well. My favorite of his piano concertos is the No. 5.

Take care and enjoy your evening.

John

lzaus 11 days ago

I am going to see two different performances of Beethoven's fifth this summer. I don't know why two groups are doing it in Chicago around the same time. But I'm going to both. I'm still interested in minor keys. What parts of the symphony should I listen for to hear the influence Beethoven had on Gershwin, Berlin, etc.

Thanks again, I hope you don't mind all these minor key questions, but I think minor key influence gives "soul" to music.

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 11 days ago

Hi lzaus, and thanks for stopping by and commenting.

I'm assuming you mean Beethoven's 5th Piano Concerto. I'll try and explain.

There's a tecnnique in composition which was rarely used before Beethoven's time (though few used it before him, it didn't become prevalent until after Beethoven did it) which is the constant modulation between the major/minor keys. If you listen to the slow movement of the 5th, you'll notice this... Additionally, Mozart uses this technique but in seperate phrases (known in music as sentences/periods) but Beethoven moves into the minor key and out of it more often than composers before him did. Slow lyrical movements are more frequent than fast movements (outer movements).

Anyways, hope you have fun. The Beethoven 5th Piano Concerto is one of my favorites.

Take care

John

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working