What is Philology?

83

By John Sarkis

Phenomenology of Philology

If a man says "I'm talking my old lady out to dinner tonight," do you think he's referring to his mother or wife? If a woman says "I'm taking my old man out to dinner tonight," do you think she's referring to her father or husband?

Phenomenology of Philology. Philology is the study of meanings and expressions in languages. Some European philologists of centuries ago would sometimes focus on people's geographic and racial attributes and connect them to their perspective languages. Some philologists thought that the "so called" Northern European Peoples (English, Dutch and German) had less rhythm and expression when they spoke than the Southern European Peoples (Italians, Spanish and Greeks), as a result; the Northern European languages tended to be more flat and dull sounding than the Southern European languages were. Furthermore, some philologists (pre Darwinian philologists) would make unfounded claims by saying that the Northern Races of Europe were more serious and steadfast than the Southern Races were.... --- Of course, today, science and psychology have proven philologists of previous centuries wrong in many of their theories....

At first, only Greek and Latin were of any consequence in Europe, with all of the other languages being considered ghetto or vernaculars. One of the first things philologists did after the modern Languages of Europe became official, was to translate The Bible from Greek and Latin to those modern languages.

‘Merry Christmas’ and ‘Feliz Navidad’ - Textual Philology
‘Merry Christmas’ and ‘Feliz Navidad’ - ‘Merry Christ’s Mass’ and ‘Happy Nativity’ are the literal meanings of these phrases. Let’s examine this phrase from a philological perspective. English is considered a Germanic Language and Spanish is considered a Romance Language (daughter language of Latin). The word happy means pleasure, and pleasure is something the English have a problem associating God with (according to philologists). The word merry means lively and cheerful - a step down from pleasure, which is the literal meaning of happy. ‘Christmas’ is a made up word by philologists and it has double meaning: ‘Christ and Mass’, or the ‘Mass of Christ’ - ‘Navidad,’ or ‘Nativity’ implies the year end season. If you ask a Spanish speaking person (who has a slight knowledge of the English language of course) how to say ‘Merry Christmas’ in Spanish, they’ll tell you ‘Feliz Navidad’, these two phrases have no literal similarities to each other whatsoever, yet for all intense and purposes mean the exact same thing - this was the work of philologists.

One of the most important contributions made by philologists was the "The King James Bible." Philologists decided to romanticize the English language by emulating Italian, French and Spanish. By doing so, they used symmetry and lyricism never the likes of before in the English Language. It wasn't until Shakespeare and Milton that English would be treated in such an eloquent and poetic fashion again.

Four of the men which influenced modern Western Culture were: Darwin, Marx, Freud and Einstein. Darwin was one of the first scientists that attempted to abolish the idea of race in his theories of evolution which he eloquently expounds upon in his magnum opus “On The Origin of Species.” Marx and Freud followed shortly after him with their ideas about sociology, human rights, and how it is that the human mind functions. Einstein discovered that gravity was a constant energy and proved Newton wrong (although some have said that Newton knew gravity was an energy and not a force, however, by admitting this, a God wouldn’t have been needed. Some have said that Newton was afraid of being accused of heresy by the then very powerful Church of England, and some have concluded this was the reason he said that a force or entity was behind the unlimited supply of energy which keeps our universe operational....). Case and point: as many people became more and more knowledgeable about science and psychology, race and religion became less and less important in European societies. Today, racial components in philology are seldom if ever used - the four branches of philology are: comparative, textual (e.g. the Merry Christmas vs. Feliz Navidad example given), cognitive and decipherment.

Final thoughts:
There are many other expressions put together by philologists. And, just like the previous example (Merry Christmas/Feliz Navidad), they have no literal similarities in common whatsoever, yet mean the exact same thing - Christmas Eve vs. Noche Buena is another good example of textual philology.... Like philosophy today, philology has taken a back seat to science and psychology.






Comments

Cammiebar profile image

Cammiebar Level 4 Commenter 3 months ago

This is a very interesting hub that really goes into the basics around philology. But this also shows how difficult it is for interpreters and translators to work. There is never a perfect translation for two languages. Even greetings. In the United States, we say "How are you?" asking without any in-depth view of a person's well being. In Mandarin, though, they ask if the person had eaten.

Interesting and voted up!

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thanks for stopping by Cammiebar. I truly appreciated.

Yes, I didn't know this about Mandarin, thanks for sharing. There are some expressions that philologists had little to do with, e.g., Happy New Year - Feliz Ano Nuevo, you know philologists were not involved in putting together this phrase because they mean the exact same thing in both English and Spanish (be it that the adjectives, subjects and predicates aren't always positioned on the same place of the sentence...)

Take care and God Bless

John

James A Watkins profile image

James A Watkins Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

I took a course in French in which the first thing the intructor said was, "English is primarily French poorly pronounced."

I surely agree about the major influence The King James Bible had on the English Language.

Overall, your article is most excellent. I enjoyed it. Well done!

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thanks James, you know how highly I think of you and your hubs...

Yes, the Normans did a real hack job with English. Of course, if they had not conquered England, English would sound very much like Germam today, because, this is what the Saxons spoke.

Thanks and take care

John

DeborahNeyens profile image

DeborahNeyens Level 7 Commenter 3 months ago

Very interesting, John. I'd never heard the term philology before. Do you have a favorite dictionary you use? I recently purchased the New Oxford American Dictionary, second edition, and found it does a really nice job tracking the origin and changing meanings of words.

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you Deborah.

Oxford American Dictionary is as good as it gets. Nietzsche was a philologist, and influenced Heidegger and Derrida, both of whom were very much interested in the human vocabulary.

Take care and thanks for stopping by!

John

Ruchira profile image

Ruchira Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

Hi John,

You enlightened me with this informative hub. Thank you!

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you so much for your kind words Ruchira.

Yes, I've always been fascinated by the origin of languages.

Take care - God Bless - Peace!

John

Peggy W profile image

Peggy W Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

What an interesting topic, that of philology! I was not familiar with the term which is what led me to reading this. It is no wonder that people have different interpretations of the Bible as well as misunderstandings among themselves when different languages are interpreted. Mixing slang meanings into language makes it even more difficult not to mention people's accents even when speaking the same language.

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you Peggy for stopping by and commenting.

Yes, so you know, since many people do not. This was the field that Nietzsche was educated in, not philosophy. Nevertheless, both philology and theology are fields that a philosopher needs to be familiar with....

Take care and God Bless

John

Vinaya Ghimire profile image

Vinaya Ghimire Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

Study of language is also in a way study of culture and civilization. This is well written article. There is so much to learn for this.

markbennis profile image

markbennis Level 6 Commenter 3 months ago

This is interesting and a great read too voted up! Also gave it a tweet…

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you Vinaya for commenting. You're absolutely correct, anthropology is an important field of study. You're from India. I'm not too knowledgeable about this, but I believe that it was about 500 or so years ago, that they started to connect Sanskrit to Western Civilization after observing that certain pronunciations in English and German were similar to Sanskrit. Don't quote me on it though, as I know very little about it....

Take care and God Bless

John

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thank you so much markbennis for stopping by and commenting. You know, I'm one of the most ignorant individuals when it comes to computers and the internet. So what ever you did---I thank you for it!

God Bless

John

dmop profile image

dmop Level 6 Commenter 3 months ago

Reading this, I am reminded of a book I once read where one of the characters is a Philologist and is able to tell people exactly where they were raised by their speech. If anyone has an idea what book that may be please let me know. It seems like it may have been a Charles Dickens novel, but I'm not sure it's been too many years I suppose. Great Hub, thanks for sharing it with us.

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

I think you're talking about Shaw's "Pygmalion"? Shaw was not a philologist (though he was extremely educated) per se; However, Shaw, Oscar Wilde and Nietzsche were all aestheticians who stronly believed in outer beauty, which is something I do not believe in.

Thank you much for stopping by and commenting. You have some really insightful hubs as well. I've enjoyed reading a couple of them already.

God Bless

John

peperuhi profile image

peperuhi 3 months ago

interesting

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hi peperuhi, glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for visiting and commenting.

Take care

John

alocsin profile image

alocsin Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

What an interesting hub for all hubbers, since we are supposed to be interested in words. Voting this Up and Interesting.

phdast7 profile image

phdast7 Level 8 Commenter 3 months ago

John - I am passionately in love with philology and all things pertaining to language and words. A really, really great Hub. My nuclear and extended families play cards and "word" games. That is it. We are all closet etymologists. :)

Don't know if you read C.S. Lewis, but he wrote a space trilogy that is a great space fantasy, but also explicates religion, faith, culture, and science without appearing in the least bit "preachy." The main character in all three books is a Dr. Ransom, from Oxford I think, who is an etymologist by profession. :) Theresa

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Thanks alocsin for stopping by and commenting.

Yes, ---well, I love Nietzsche, he's one of my favorite philosophers, yet, he was a philologist by profession. Words fascinate me.

Take care

John

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 3 months ago

Hi phdast7, you're ever so kind...thanks for commenting.

Yes, I'm fascinated with words because I speak both Spanish and English. I'm always comparing words in my mind..., it's non stop for me. I hear the word "doctor" for example, and I know it's Latin because it's the exact same word in both English and Spanish. The word "God" is a Germanic/Nordic word, because, the equivalent in Spanish is "Dios," and these two words have nothing in common with each other...and so on and so on....

Take care

John

AudreyHowitt profile image

AudreyHowitt Level 7 Commenter 2 months ago

Very interesting John--so can we separate literal translation from context at all? I ask this as I have an interest in the "mistakes" made in translating scripture from original text to Latin, Greek, etc--

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 2 months ago

Thanks Audrey for stopping by and commenting.

There are many mistakes in languages. This is what Heidegger and Derrida's work was all about. Did you ever stop to think that the word "woman" is merely a syllable added to the word "man?" "Woman" is unique from "man," yet, because man ruled the world when languages were constructed all he did was to add a syllable to his name....

Take care

John

AudreyHowitt profile image

AudreyHowitt Level 7 Commenter 2 months ago

I do think about that--I also think about the term "companion" and what that meant in biblical times and how that meaning has changed. I must say, I do love words!

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 2 months ago

You're so right...I never thought of that word...interesting. I also love words very much.

Thanks again and take care

John

daffodil2010 profile image

daffodil2010 2 weeks ago

interesting hub i like it and voted up

John Sarkis profile image

John Sarkis Hub Author 2 weeks ago

Thanks for stopping by daffodil2010 and commenting on my hub and, for following me---returned the favor by following you as well.

Yes, philology is a hobby of mine.

Enjoy the start of your week

John

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working